Pizza Johns - Carlisle

Pizza Johns is awesome. Their pizza is great and reasonably priced, cheeseburger sub was awesome, it had grilled onions which was excellent, the fries are awesome as well. Ordered a lamb gyro with fries and was more than satisfied, it had ALOT of lamb meat so that was really cool. I honestly can not wait to try more food from there. The staff are really friendly. I hope this pizza shop stays here for good.

Great food and great price such a nice taste great service

Placed an order for two pizzas and some wings online. I received an email that said the order would be ready in 20 to 30 minutes. I'm not sure if there was a mix up with the time or what, but when I arrived to pick up my order (about 35 minutes after receiving the email), it was still being made. Took 50 minutes total to get the order. Beyond that, the food was okay. Not the best pizza I've ever had, but not the worst. Same with the wings.

The pizza was great. We 've gotten the 'Meatster ' and a pepperoni pizza so far. Lots of cheese, lots of flavor in the sauce and crust! My only complaint is the timing. Twice now I 've been given a ready time of 15 mins and 25 mins and had to wait an additional 30 mins each time till the pizza was actually ready.