Sheila's Pizza - Elmore County

I have been eating this pizza for a decade! Have loved it. In the past few months, I have ordered pizzas that were not specifically the way they were ordered. I love spinach alfredo. Got pizza with literally no spinach! My husband loves black olives, there were almost none of that topping on his pizza! We are done with overpriced pizza that doesn't includes the toppings that we asked for!

Ordered at 7:09, they told me 30 to 45 minutes for a friday thats understandable. When u receive it an hour and ten minutes later and there not but 2 miles up the road. That is a little much. The pizzas on the bottom were both very undercooked, almost to the point of raw. As u can see. I haven't really had good luck with this place ever since ordering here. You alone can only determine to go eat here or order delivery. I think this will be the last time for me. Oooo and the people that give this place a good review are friends and locals just trying to make it look good.

We didn't eat in, but I went and got the pizza. Fast and efficient service. Pizza was great!

I dream of Sheila's Pizza! In fact got some left over fixin' to heat it up right now!

The girls that answer the phone sound like they are 10 years old and mumble so they cannot be understood. They need to learn to speak up and enunciate, not sound like blblubla.