Aunt Cookies Sub Shop - Geneseo

When my boyfriend said he wanted to drive 45 for a sub, I was skeptical. How could a sub be different, unique, and amazing?? Well it was worth the drive! I think the main thing that sets them apart is that they slightly toast the bread prior to putting anything in it which gives it a really nice taste and texture I don't know any other sub place that does this. Plus they don't skimp on the meats or sauces, and the quality is really good. Definitely the best sub shop around!!

FANTASTIC sub. I wish my companions had told me that this place makes its own bread as we had limited time and had to sort of wolf it down but it was delicious and the bread was terrific. Definitely be aware that it's going to take an extra 10 minutes or so more than places that don't do fresh bread but it is totally worth it

This tiny sub shop in the heart of Geneseo is a perfect spot to grab some excellent sandwiches and cookies. Their bread is freshly made in house and has a great crispy crust and the inside is perfect too, not being too hard or too spongy. Toppings were excellent and my ham and cheese came with a type of mayo/slaw which I loved. Definitely will stop again to try some of their other specials.

My daughter attends SUNY Geneseo and we were on our way for a hike when we came across this charming little sandwich shop. The food was all fantastic. The freshly baked bread rolls were particularly tasty, as were the cookies. We can't wait to visit again.

Here in NY, you always hear about Wegmans subs. But these guys blow Wegmans so far out of the water, it's insane. Every sub tastes amazing. I even forgot to add veggies on one of mine recently, and still topped over Wegmans. Service is great, cute little dining room. This is the place to go if you want subs.