Black Sheep Bagels - Jamesport

6 bucks for a bagel with this much cream cheese… we get it inflation with all the signs all over the store but I feel 6 bucks should get you more cream cheese than this!!!Also it took the staff 20 min to help 2 people

Just left the bagel store which I frequent maybe once a week since opening. Waited 10 minutes for a buttered bagel, which I requested toasted with light butter, bagel is drenched in butter, soaked through the wax paper and paper bag onto my seat. The fact of the matter is why does it take 4 employees to make each order that they take? Four employees standing around, making each individual sandwich while customers stand around waiting. Why not have a cook that does all the cooking, this way people that just want bagel can be in and out in less then 5 minutes, instead of 10 minutes. Half my bagel is going in the garbage, soaked in butter. I understand it was toasted, use less butter. Very disappointed. I would have preferred to speak directly with owner, Chris, but he was not present. Next time I am there and he is there I will speak directly to him.

Amazing bagel options. The onion bagel with jalapeno cream cheese we got was delicious. Perfect spot for breakfast. It gets crowded on weekends but worth the wait.

Great bagels and great staff. Clean and reasonable prices. Highly recommend!

By far the best bagels on the North Fork with a team to match. Can't recommend highly enough.