Captain John's - McConnellsville

Key West vibes, full of personality and the service is fantastic. Always my suggested first welcoming spot to friends family when traveling into the Sylvan Beach area.

My dad and I went out to eat here yesterday! Neither of us ever ate here before but we decided to try it out. We got there and immediately got seated, and the staff were amazing. Everybody was so kind, and the server we had, Brady, was absolutely amazing. (My dad was also really impressed with him, and even said to me that our server Brady was the first good server he's had in at least 30 years). The food was amazing, we shared a Rodeo BBQ burger and I think it was one of the BEST burgers I've ever had, genuinely. The decor was AMAZING!! It was so cool inside, both decoration wise and temperature as well lol. We are definitely coming back to eat here again in the future!!

Captain John greeted us at the front door. His energy and personality are phenomenal. The atmosphere was fun. The Parrot Punch was outstanding. The food was excellent, especially the cheesecake made with Grandma's recipe. The service was terrific. Overall, super fun and enjoyable time. Will be back.

First time there. The food was great. The service was amazing. And the atmosphere was fitting. A huge applause for our waiter Brady who was by far the best waiter i have had in a long time. I will be back ?

Food was great. I loved the atmosphere. Drinks were so good