Mcaloon's - New Shoreham

The restaurant forgot to place my order, and since everyone else was eating, no one checked in with me. I had to get up and ask about my meal. When the salmon finally arrived, it was overcooked and fell apart—definitely not enjoyable.

Great experience here! To start off, the food was fantastic, I was only here for appetizers however, those appetizers absolutely blew me away. I decided to do some restaurant hopping around the area, this Cheesy Garlic Bread with the French Onion Soup was just amazing. The sauce with the toasted bread and cheese with other flavoring on top also was really delicious, the French Onion Soup, Wow, absolutely delicious, also the mix of flavoring especially the cheese on top. Everything will melt in your mouth, it was awesome. The service was fantastic, our waitress was really sweet, gave us recommdations of the best dishes at the restaurant, made sure the food was great and more. The atmosphere of the place was great! Despite eating outside, the outside tables and chairs were clean, the interior looked awesome too! There was a bar with a bunch of other seating inside too, nice lighting and large TV’s. The live music also made the experience a lot more fun as well. This restaurant was definetly a restaurant that I would come back to if I would come back to Block Island. I would highly recommend this restaurant to others who are coming to vacation here or to spend a whole day here. Parking: There is a gas station near by which is owned by the same building, there should be parking in that area, however, there is also street parking.

McAloon’s remains a favorite spot on Block Island for a substantial meal. We recently dined there and it certainly lived up to our expectations. Whether you're in the mood for an excellent Shepherd’s Pie or a straightforward Chicken Tenders Platter, you won’t be let down.

We were seated on the patio and waited for 25 minutes without being served. Every table around us received their meals, and we even asked the people at the table next to us to let their server know about our long wait. The server acknowledged it with an "oh" and then walked away without addressing us. Frustrated, we decided to leave.

It's really good and not too pricey. Chicken Parm was good.