Old Island Pub - New Shoreham

Awesome small tavern with an older vibe. Nice vs. the alternatives.

There’s a reason this place was empty on a Saturday in August. The food was dry and over cooked, the drinks were diluted and the bartender was completely disrespectful. (Older lady). There are sooo many better bars on the island that actually appreciate your business!

My absolute favorite place to eat off season. You MUST get the pub fries with the proprietary dipping sauce! My go- to is always the broccoli Reuben (vegetarian). It NEVER disappoints. The staff is so very friendly as well.

Great pizza and pub fries, great bartender (tom), great people on a calm Easter Sunday. Can't go wrong with this pub.

Taco Tuesday is to die for here. The food is always fresh and delicious. The specials are always amazing. I've yet to have a bad meal at this place.