Big City Deli Pizzeria - Rochester

They treated me to free pizza for my birthday, the staff member was incredibly friendly, and the food was fantastic!

Delicious food, spotless environment, and welcoming staff...

The slices are overpriced given the lack of quality—$5 for a thin, average-sized pepperoni slice is not worth it. There are much better options nearby. What really turned me off was the use of low-quality blue cheese, which is a major faux pas for WNY pizza. I understand they mostly cater to the late-night bar crowd who aren't too picky at 1 a.m., but if they want to attract customers at other times, they need to improve their offerings. On the positive side, the staff was friendly, and I did get a free drink with two slices, which made it a bit more bearable. However, I definitely wish I had chosen a different place.

Thank you for sharing a slice of pizza with me! It was delicious, and I definitely recommend trying it. The staff was wonderful, and I really appreciated the friendliness they showed. Thanks again, and I’ll be back! (From a DoorDash/UberEATS driver)

Ordered a pizza from them last night from dooradoor dash andIand when iiI received it looked like a 5 year old made it. Three slices were crust only and all the meat had become soup in the middle of the pizza. I have never in my life ever received such a horrible pizza in NY. I would not recommend the pizza. Extremely disappointed especially because it was very expensive.