Anthony's Pizza - Altamonte Springs

I recently decided to try this pizza place after getting tired of Broadway and Papa John's, and I’m so glad I did. It was one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time, made with the freshest ingredients and bursting with flavor. The staff was incredibly friendly and even prepared a pizza just 10 minutes before closing, and it was just as delicious as the first one I ordered. I will definitely be returning and becoming a regular customer. Give it a try! They treat you with kindness and genuinely care about their pizzas and customers.

I've been to this restaurant several times, and it has always been a great experience. However, during my recent visit, we sat outside and the staff completely overlooked us. Even after we went inside to remind them, they still forgot our drinks and part of our order. I managed to get the food packed into to-go boxes in time, but the staff had a bit of an attitude about it. There’s no reason it should take 45 minutes to get a slice of pizza and some garlic knots.

Last week we ordered Chicken Marsala (was good) and Veal Parmigiana to go. The Veal was tough and had grizzle all throughout. We called and were told that the Veal was like that because we ?didn?t eat it fast enough?. The owner said he would give us a replacement. I called today to order a pizza to go. We should have opened it before we left. It took us 10 minutes to get home and once we opened the box this is what we got. The grease is so heavy all over, especially with the pepperoni. A little grease is normal this thick amount is not. The paper towel shows what I soaked up from the mushroom half!!! We?ve gotten better pizza from WALMART!!! We will never set foot into this place again.

Hands down, this is the BEST pizza I have had in Florida. It reminds me of NY style pizza. Excellent taste and perfect crust. All of the people who work there are very nice. I also enjoy the laid back atmosphere when we dine in. Try it! You won't be disappointed. (April 2021)

This is the best NY style pizza I 've found in Florida. They have nice salads and appetizers, but I really come here for the pizza. It 's a traditional pizza oven style, and it really is close to perfect every single time. Super easy to recommend to anyone looking for NY style pizza.