Best Pizza Dive - Amagansett

Love this place ... great pizza and a laid back vibe.Had an issue with Ubereats and Tony made it all better.Look up barstool sports pizza review.

We camped at Hither Hills and came here like 3 times lol. My husband and I called it pizza and activities center. First off, the pizza is great, and actually better than most pizza joints on long island. They have ping pong, corn hole, pool...activities! Outdoor picnic area. Indoor seating and live music! We loved it. Will definitely go back next time we are out that way.

Tonight, I witnessed a movie. Horrible pizza would compare it to seven eleven pizza. To top this off I observed a middle age man screaming and yelling at a minor, this disgusting scene was done by a higher up employee “manager/owner”. I am a local and I am infuriated at this situation I will surely never be coming back. Pleased that they changed the name from best pizza to dive bar pizza surely the pizza isn’t the best pizza.??

It’s really nice to have a spot like this in the area that can honestly be a little stuffy. They have a laid back vibe, live music and great pizza. Their sauce was amazing, the garlic knots were great, and had a variety of pizza toppings.

They burn their pizza and it’s doughy. It wasn’t that good. Wait time is a bit ridiculous. Not a big enough kitchen space. The back is also kind of lame. Why is there a random skate ramp that no one is allowed to use or even touch? Just a big piece of junk taking up space that could be used for better things. Also a complete eyesore. Overall don’t recommend this place until they improve sole of these things!