The Rivers And Supper Club - Amherst

We visited The Rivers Bar Supper Club early on a Saturday evening for dinner. We had a group of about 10 people, and they were easily able to accommodate our group; we were seated right away. We had a pleasant dining experience with good food and good drinks in a classic Wisconsin supper club environment. There was only one gentleman working it seemed other than whoever was in the kitchen), and he served both a few patrons at the bar as well as waited on our table. We were the only party in the restaurant at the time, but I still found this impressive. The menu was standard supper club fare. Everyone in our group ordered the prime rib except me), which came with a solid soup and salad bar. We shared an appetizer sampler that included some good mozzarella sticks and jalapeno poppers. I opted for the walleye sandwich. Although plain in presentation, it was delicious and a large portion. I went with the house made fries which were thin and crispy instead of the frozen crinkle cut someone in our group who tried both said they preferred the house made). My significant other chose the hash browns with his prime rib we both agreed these were delicious. I tried a few bites of the prime rib as well, and I thought it was good. All in all, we had a good experience at The Rivers. The service was great, the atmosphere was traditional, and the food was good. The food was a little on the pricey side $20/plate), but the portions were definitely large. The drinks were inexpensive; they had an old fashioned special going that night of $3.50/drink. I don't normally order cocktails but being in a supper club it seemed like the thing to do, so I went with a brandy old fashioned sweet with olives. I was pretty satisfied with it! I would recommend checking it out for dinner and drinks.

The food was great. Good fish selections but the atmosphere needs to be improved. They need to add more paintingsto be called a supper club. The price was reasonable which included salad bar and soup bar but the salad bar was very basic. The soups were homemade and excellent. The tables needed some nice tealights or candles.

Good food and friendly service! Traditional Wisconsin supper club nice change up from all of the chain restaurants that keep popping up everywhere!

Good food but the cook doesn’t know the difference between well done and rare

When you move to a small village you find yourself hoping to make friends and feel attached to the place you now call home. Well, coming to Rivers Bar Supper Club gives you both of those things from the very first moment you walk through the door. You feel like you've just come home because you're greeted like a friend and you're fed like one of the family too. This place makes going out for a drink and dinner a cozy, warm and fun time. I highly recommend this place, especially if you're looking for that Wisco Supper Club experience it's spot on!