Earl's 377 Pizza - Argyle

We love Earl's! We go about once a month because we live nearby. They allow dogs inside their covered patio (even in the air conditioned portion during hot summer days), and our dog Howdy just loves the attention and the ability to do happy hour with us. Their pizza is always amazing, drinks are great, salads are awesome, and we've never had bad service in the 20+ times we've been.

My wife and I headed out to a new place for us in Argyle called Earl's 377. Seemed like a great little place for date night when we walked in and a huge patio awaits the good weather months. All the folks there were very nice and welcoming. It seemed pretty slow even for a Tuesday night as there were only 3 tables including us at 7:15 or so. The menus are neat antique clipboard style and very simple to understand. My wife got a beer for like $6.5 and I got a margarita for $10 and a $3 Grand Marnier topper. Everything seemed to start out right. We put in our order of lasagna, Caesar salad, and a meatball sub. With so few tables in the place I was surprised at the length of time it took to get food out. The salad was first to arrive and I will say a small salad of $8 will be more than enough for four people to start out the meal with. They add artichokes to it which I think are ok, but just a warning in case you don't like them. I asked for a side of anchovies and they came out. Certainly they're the canned variety. I'd say the salad could have used a little more dressing. Their forks are also quite unique, neither good nor bad for me, but curved like a spoon and tines like a fork. Certainly a spork if I've ever seen one. About ten minutes after Nonna's meatball sandwich came out to us. Perhaps I'm used to a lot more sauce when it comes to this type of sandwich but I will say it came out with no sauce, caked in mozzarella, and very bland. Pepper chips came with it as an included side which I thought were ok. The meatballs were moist but just nothing head and shoulders above other places. For $15 I'd be inclined to say it's not much value either between price, quantity, and flavor. Though the sandwich came out in decent time, there was enough time for us to play shuffleboard as it was nearby our table. It's free and shows the wear and tear of customers use, but was nonetheless a nice way to pass the time. We were thankful it was there because it took another 20 minutes for the Vita Mia lasagna to come out. Again perhaps it's homemade and takes time to make, but 25-30 mins from order to table seems like a bit much. The edges seemed burned and the bottom was even worse. Bolognese style is the description but not sure they'd give their thumbs up for this one, especially for $17. Meals aren't really big enough for two except for the salad, unless you have smaller appetites. Thanks to the staff for being so cordial, but it's the food that keeps people coming back and I'd be hard-pressed to make another trip here other than to sit out on the patio and have a few drinks. In addition there were enough fruit flies buzzing around our table to be a significant turn-off for the place.

Only the Tiramisu for dessert is outstanding. I 'm an original New Englander from Cape Cod. But even IF you call their style of pizza New York or yankee it still lacks a flavorful pizza sauce even though it 's thin style. But to each their own. It 's clean and friendly with both indoor and outdoor seating so if you have kids and don 't mind the noise or uncomfortable chairs it would be good for family night. The service is fast and wait staff pleasant. Just not my particular style. C 'est la vie... In summation Life 's short eat dessert 1st.

Great place for a big salad and good pizza day. We've been coming to Earls for many years now and it's always great! friendly, quick service and the ambience is always pleasant.

I highly recommend this place. Our family has been there several times and love the food and service. I also enjoy the ambiance. We will definitely will be coming back soon.