Acme Pie Company - Arlington

The most delicious pies I've ever had! Most highly recommended!!! Try something savory and take something sweet home for later.

Updated review: STILL 5/5 Pies: Crust is still amazing as always. Their pies aren't too sweet, so eating a slice doesn't feel like a struggle. Their fruit pies are particularly special. I had the seasonal blackberry peach today and it was a dream! I could taste some peaches, but the proportions were so well done it tasted like a brand new fruit creation! Pinball machines??: I didn't realize they installed pinball machines! They're super old school and free to play. I definitely spent 20 mins enjoying it Went home with quiche, a chilled banoffee pie, and a slice of sour cherry. Thanks Acme for being phenomenal--I'm thrilled everytime I get a bite here

Quaint little pie shop is a hidden gem in Arlington, thank goodness we found it using yelp. The staff Anabelle and Lila were friendly and welcoming, had great suggestions. The other locals in the shop made our little stop for pie very nice. They sat and chatted with us visitors as they had puzzle night Friday night routine . It was a lovely choice for a little slice of heaven.

Came in 30 mins before closing on a Thursday. We were greeted nicely. There was a couple ahead of us ordering a bunch of slices. Older women comes from around the corner and asks what pie we want. Two slices of key lime pie please. Mind you, there were only about three slices left of the pie, and still, so close to closing shop for the day, the woman cuts two extremely TINY and unevenly measured slices of pie for $15. The flavor was pretty good but we felt cheated. When I 'm charged $6+ dollars for a slice of pie, I expect a healthy slice!

The only experience I've had with Acme Pie so far is with their Cookies which I discovered at a library function they were THE BEST!!! I plan to stop by one of these days to peruse their pies and bring one home.