The Knuckle Sandwich - Bargersville

First time eating at this cool little 50’s diner. Our server Haley was friendly and made excellent recommendations. The hubcap tenderloin was soft fried, large and not super thin. Tasted great! The onion rings were excellent as well. My son said his cheeseburger and fries were perfect! Definitely a place I would visit again. Check this place out if you get a chance. PS I already ate half of my onion rings but you can get a look at the size of the sandwich. It could feed two. lol

I went for breakfast and I enjoyed the experience. My table mate did not. Both of us agree that our waitress was beyond phenomenal I mean she was absolutely awesome. She was experienced, carismatic, and ready to serve the guests. Honestly this woman should be working at a high end restaurant her skills were so good. That 's almost impossible to find these days. My table mate on the other hand did not enjoy her omelette. After a hard night of drinking she complained about the consistency of the omelette she had and that the bacon pieces were not cut to her standard of being acceptable. I 'll go back fo sho. My table mate would rather go to the gas station for a sandwich...

I like the vibe of this restaurant, and service is really good, but I’m never really impressed with its food. It’s alright, but not great to me.

This restaurant might lack in a four star atmosphere but without a doubt doesn't fall short on taste. Casual pleasant staff. But so obviously getting the job done. My waiter was Jason. Wasn't the best conversationalist but definitely made up by doing the job in spades anticipating what we wanted and needed. If anything I would suggest would staff is most likely underpaid considering there putting out four star food and service. They had a very casual dress but if it makes them happy. Let them dress anyway they want. Excellence at its best. Everything thing was clean. Welcoming in everyway. Keep this up and your going to have to make reservations. Just to mention the bacon was cooked perfectly. And the cobbler was an exquisite masterpiece.

Love The Knuckle! We haven't been since they reopened in their new location and happy to see that it's still great!