Barnegat Bay Ice Cream

We love Barnegat Bay when we go there in person! This is the second time ive done delivery and the milkshakes come super thin/liquidy. They end up sitting while waiting for the driver. They should make them a little thicker for a pickup order!

Everything was excellent, as usual. As I've mentioned in my previous reviews, I order from here at least twice a week. The quality is always consistent and very enjoyable. It's the best ice cream shop in the area, and their water ice is fantastic!

I tried the Piña Colada Milkshake, which featured a delicious blend of piña colada Italian ice and coconut ice cream. I also had the Twist Soft Serve Sundae, available in chocolate and vanilla, topped with rainbow sprinkles and served with cookie dough bites on the side.

I order from this place at least 2 to 3 times a week. The soft serve sundaes are fantastic, and the chocolate-covered bananas are equally amazing. The Brownie Overboard is a must-try for any chocolate lover. Everything here is incredible!

Every time I order, its always great as always.