Il Castello's - Barryville

Jennifer and the kitchen staff helped create and prepare some of the finest dishes our family has ever enjoyed. They catered my sister's baby shower, and without their contributions, the event wouldn't have been nearly as wonderful. The delicious food truly brought everyone together. We're so grateful for your prompt and excellent service. Thank you all from the Parachinni family!

Pizza joints often serve great cheesesteaks, and the one I had here was among the best I've ever tasted—plus, it was massive! I finished the entire thing and hardly made a dent in my cheese fries because I was so full! I definitely plan to return to try the pizza sometime, assuming I don’t end up at the cardiologist's office, haha.

Absolutely the best pizza I've ever had! The flavor is unmatched, and we always prioritize dining here whenever we visit.

I've had pizza all over the world and this is by far the best Margherita Pizza I've ever had! Amazing chocolate dipped cannoli. Great sandwiches too. Can't wait to make a special trip back next time I'm around!

I have eaten Peter's pizza for most of my life, 25 years of his pizza. It's almost always great. There have been some pizza cooks that have come and gone who didn't always have the greatest pies, but generally you can expect a great slice. Decent prices for the pizza, and many specialty slices. I also like some of their dinners, and they have excellent hot and cold subs. I'm admittedly not a huge fan of some of their lunch menu items burgers and the like. One complaint I paid 9 dollars for a single slice of tiramisu, factoring in the credit card extra charge, but it's too pricey with or without the credit card charge added.