Nicky's Clam - Bay Shore

Wait here for the ferry with my best mate. we had oysters Calamari with a few pint beers. Very nice staff that could thank me for my service, even if I was a Brit, but they overheard our conversation as my best mate was an Ex-US Marine. Can't the oysters enough that they were sooo fresh and tasty (some of the best I had in years). Didn't take photos that was a shame!!

Anyone who takes the ferry from Bayshore to Ocean Beach, Fire Island or other communities knows how wonderful this restaurant is. From the seafood bisque and the Clam Chowder (try mixed red and white and take home a quarter) to the Clam or Oyster Barge, and even her egg on a roo and coffee is all excellent. I can't say enough good things about this restaurant. Immerse yourself or quickly take off your open window. New outdoor dining area. And try their donuts!

A little hidden gem with tasty food and great drinks with options for those who don't eat seafood. A bit pricier then you would expect but had great customer service. Id recommend giving this place a visit.

Please keep this a secret, but I have discovered an incredible little restaurant that feels too good to be true! I've been consistently impressed here for 25 years. You absolutely cannot miss their famous Nicky's seafood bisque—it's legendary! I also highly recommend the Nicky’s Streamer (Long Island Streamers); it's the best around and features a secret recipe you won't find anywhere else. There's so much more to love about this place. Just remember, shhh—let's keep this between us!

I ordered the stuffed clams I usually get from Lenny's Clam Bar, and I must say they are just as delicious. It's hard to find stuffed clams that compare to Lenny's, so I’m thrilled to discover another spot where you should definitely go and try them!