That's Amore Pizzeria - Bayport

We had ordered dinner the other night and the food was terrible the shrimp parm dinner tasted like it was marinated in lemons very lemony which was strange never had shrimp parm like that we ordered a well done pizza that was the worst pizza we ever had please do yourself a favor and Never go to this so called restaurant

We used to consistently order from here. The delivery guys were nice and we liked that the sauce wasn 't too sweet. Clearly, the manager doesn 't care about keeping customers, though. We ordered two specialty pies for delivery a couple weekends ago. Spent $60 dollars. First, what was promised as a half hour delivery was over an hour and the pies were cold. One was nothing like the menu description- what was supposed to be a crispy, thin crust was a Sicilian crust. The best part- they completely left the cheese off the other pie, though the description said smothered in mozzarella. No cheese at all! How do you forget the CHEESE on PIZZA? My husband (one of the calmest and nicest people you 'll ever meet, by the way) called and the manager could care less. Didn 't apologize, made no offer to make good- nothing. All he said was I 'll talk to the guys in the back. Thanks. That did me and my guests, who I just served crappy pizza to, a whole lot of good. No more. We switched to Sal 's. Should have known with such a terrible name like That 's Amore.

You will find no love at this place. Do not let the name fool you. There are no specials at all. A regular neo slice will run you 3 bucks. The people that work there are mad. No good. Never again. He's ripping off his whole town. No thank you Grumpy Greedy man.

Went here tonight to grab a quick dinner with a good friend. Upon asking found out that their white pizza has fresh garlic on it. Unfortunately, I'm allergic to fresh garlic. Garlic powder and garlic that has had the **** cooked out of it is fine but fresh is a no go for me. Was really disappointed as I wanted a white slice and a regular slice. Guy behind the counter said he could make me my own personal pizza 1/2 white and 1/2 regular. He did just that and it was delicious. Thank you for being so accommodating and for the yummy pizza! Will definitely be back.

I really appreciate the new owners. They are such pleasant people, and the restaurant is incredibly clean. The pizza is fantastic, and the rice balls are absolutely delicious!