The Pizzeria Bayport

Disappointed. I saw a lot of good reviews about this place. Ordered a large pepperoni. Very salty and greasy— not for me personally. Pizza was steeply priced, which was off putting considering the pizza did not live up to the reviews for me. Management is top notch and upon reaching out, made it right for me. The manager was confident that the pizza that I got was not up to par with the norm so I will try again eventually. He was very nice and assured me that he was truly sorry for my experience. That type of service and humility is not easy to find in today’s world.

Great pizza and service. Highly recommend the crumbling vodka pie.

AMAZING BEST SICILIAN PIZZA HERE AND AT BAYSHORE LOCATION.

From their specialty slices to their regular pizza, absolutely delicious! I recommend a couple of these standouts to try: Thai sesame chicken pizza, the white pizza, and the meatball and burrata pizza.

Pizza and food is fantastic and reasonably priced. Staff is fast, kind and professional. Only criticism is small parking lot and lack of parking sometimes make it difficult to park (not a fault of the pizzeria). Try this place out, you won’t regret it.