One Eye Jack's - Bethpage

Under new property, called Nostalgia . Really cool bar, nice layout, good drinks, good food, friendly barkeepers and a GREAT Vibe. You should check this place!

Beautiful little Dive Bar in the middle of Long Island. The drinks specials are quite awesome, including their $2 Jello shots. Coming from the city to see prices like this, I'm excited. I ordered four shots on a long Island iced tea and a rum and coke and paid less than $30. But the drinks aren't the reason I left this night. They have open microphone evenings from Monday to Friday and Afton organized an event with some musical artists. My little nephew was one of the actors, so it was cool for him to have a stage to show his talents. There were about 25 to 30 people in the building, not a packed house, but a good amount of people. That means I don't want to come here if they were much more than 25 to 30 people because it started to get cramped. A bad note there is no parking outside as they share the lot with three other restaurants, so come with your friends.

I always have a great time at Eye Jacks with pleasant staff working behind the bar.

Had a great time at One Eye Jack's. Pete and Lisa are amazing.

I can't believe those who rated this restaurant 4 stars. You really need to go out more. The bartenders were terrible, in all my 56 years of experience, I've never encountered worse service. Go somewhere else instead.