Key West Key Lime Pie - BIG PINE KEY

The shop was a little out of the way in a shopping plaza a few blocks off the main road. Watch out for the feral rooster and chicken population in the parking lot and grounds. a standard traditional pie is $17.99. I have no benchmark to compare that to, but I can say it was worth the price. They have a good selection of other key lime goods as well. I only wish they had a plate, fork and napkin kit that came with the pies.

Best Key Lime Pie ever!!!! It's $3.99 for a slice or $17.99 for an entire pie. I recommend the entire pie. I still like Original best, but the mango and pineapple coconut are interesting too. They also have good souvenir gifts, such as key lime mustard, BBQ sauce, and key lime pie kits.

I had difficulty finding this place. It's in a shopping center that's hidden behind trees. This place is a small spot next to Winn Dixie. I tried the Pineapple Key Lime Pie. It was tarty yet sweet which chunks of pineapple.

Best key lime pie i've had. Not too tart and not too sweet, a perfect balance for this key west treat. My whole family loved it so much we will be back from NY next year for a taste.

As a key lime pie enthusiast, my husband and I make it a point to return from our trips to the Keys with a cooler filled with these delicious pies. We discovered a shop conveniently located near our hotel in the Big Pine Key Winn Dixie Shopping Plaza after a challenging 45-minute search in Key West. In addition to their famous pies, they also offer a variety of key lime products and souvenirs. They even ship their pies via FedEx, though this option can be quite expensive.