Nonno Lorenzo's Pizza - Branchville

Never again! Second time ordering from here. First time was amazing this time, horrible. Ordered our food for pick up, got home and realized our food was wrong I know should have checked there but we only live down the road). We called to let them know, and were willing to bring back. The owner very rudely said we got what we paid for and proceeded to call my brother in law an “f-ing idiot”. This place is a real class act!

Last time I 'll Order Here! New owner has really let this place go downhill. An hour and a half for our order tonight and once again, the food was mediocre. The Italian sub... I can get better at Quick Chek and Jersey Mike 's. The sub roll seemed processed, not fresh. The meat was cut so thick and was watery. Barely any lettuce and hardly any oil and vinegar. Lasagna was OK. Meatball sub...meatballs seemed processed too. Chicken salad was OK, but not for the price. Garlic knots... half raw and I couldn 't taste any garlic. SO disappointing, especially after waiting for so long. We 've had pizza here before as well. You can find much better elsewhere in Sussex county. My recommendation: Keep looking.

I almost never leave a review but after reading some of these I feel I must comment. Was happy to see pizza in this spot again and thought we'd try it. The pizza was the best we have had locally in years. Fresh veggies, including mushrooms, perfect crust not too thick or thin, tasty sauce and perfect cheese. The owner was friendly and as of this writing the New staff also friendly as I walked in. The pizza is large and filling and CONSISTENT each time we order. Subs have enough meat and cheese that you don't feel like you are eating a bread sandwich, and the oil vinegar is unique and awesome! We are working our way through the menu and everything has been delicious and portions hearty. I am saddened by some previous reviews saying unkind things about the owner as we have found him very friendly from the opening. He always greets us and even when busy he will stick his head by window to say a quick hello. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion so I hope if you are reading this you will try Nonno's and decide for yourself! Overall Great food, reasonable prices and Large portions we always have leftovers even when it's just a plain pie which is not common. ?

Stopped in to order a White Pie with Broccoli. Counter service was lacking. Chef yelling from the kitchen to the front of the house. Two younger girls working there were just sitting on their phones. No pleasantries, kinda rude actually. When we got home to eat the (over $20) pizza, we couldn't get through more than two bites. It was loaded, and I mean LOADED, with cheese. I'm actually not sure there was any crust under it! I may have been willing to give it a second chance, but the service sealed the deal. Do not recommend.

I recently ate here and I have to say it was the best pizza I have had in such a long time. The last time I had pizza like this was in New York City. the owner Charlie is a gentleman. I’ve seen these nasty reviews, if you show him the proper respect then he is polite and respectful, I would happily eat here again! 5/5 stars! So much better than AGs in branchville, the pizza is burnt and the people are nasty… definitely would recommend this place