New York Pizzeria - Canastota

Tiny little pizza place, but big flavor. Everytime I get pizza or wings here they are delicious. Definitely love coming here. No problems thus far. It is a small place though, but has been around my entire life.

Will not be buying pizza from there again. When you ask for your pizza not to be burnt and it still comes burnt there's a problem. I shouldn't have to ask for Less sauce either. So too much sauce burnt pizza I pay $40 for two pizzas and they're both disgusting. I don't know why it's such an issue to ask for Less sauce and not a burnt pizza?

Ordered a Calzone and it was SO GREASY that I had to cut it open let it drain out completely then rebake it in my oven... Definitely should fix the menu prices as well since that throws you for a loop when you order and it comes out 20$ more than expected....New to town def trying to find something better I don't have to rebake on my own

Good, I saw 4 people cone in to make orders in 15 minutes AND on a nice Saturday afternoon!

The food has absolutely gone down hill, they don't have a warmer for their slices, they have to heat them up in the oven, the dress code for the women is appalling, short, very short shorts, shirts that aren't even professional, and they are very rude, I wouldn't recommend this place!!!!! Got absolutely sick on their food, pizza and a Como platter, never again!!!!!