Stefano's Pizzeria - Carthage

The food here is excellent! I tried the calzone, and it was fantastic. The jalapeño poppers are the best I've tasted so far!

My husband and I stopped in for lunch around noon. We ordered a half-cold sub, fries, and a soda for just $9.85. What an excellent deal! The sub was delicious, and although I'm not usually a fan of coated fries, these were hot and well-seasoned. Overall, with such unbeatable prices, I have to give this place a solid 5 stars!

Years ago, when I was stationed at Fort Drum, my wife and I lived in one of the apartments above the restaurant. We indulged in their pizza at least twice a month. After moving from the desert southwest, I fell in love with New York-style pizza thanks to this place.

Great family history! We had Sicilian pepperoni with jalapeno peppers and it was huge... 16 pieces. Pizza and garlic bread were fantastic, service was fast and friendly.

2022 edit Must have repainted in there it's been a while but it looks and feels great! 2016 visit Some of the best eggplant parmesan I've had. That's my test of a good Italian restaurant. This claims to be a pizzeria, but honestly, they do a lot more than just pizza.