Fishtales Hideaway - City of Batavia

They wanted to charge a high surcharge because we wanted reservations for 14 for dinner and drinks. No way! Never again. I know of no other Batavia restaurant that tries such a thing. ?

Very disappointing how 14 people wanted to get together for dinner and go to a restaurant we went to precovid. This restaurant was going to charge us a party charge of normally $75 but would only charge us $50 instead. We said no thank you and taking our business to a place that will not charge us for getting together for dinner.

We liked the quaint area to eat in past bar. Food tasty, good selection for all. Service was attentive and friendly. Portions adequate. Great place for dinner. Will be back!

We had an amazing experience here! Music, food and service was impeccable. Thank you Valerie for an awesome first time experience! We will be back for sure!

Absolutely amazing if I could have given it 10 Stars I would. By far the best seafood I've ever had in New York state.