Bagels By The Bay - City of New York

Excellent. This place is great for breakfast or lunch. I have had breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches and they have all been great. Very accommodating to some special request asked of them as well! We will continue to go here for the great food and service.

Great Place. Great bagel! Living out in San Fran, we do not get bagels that taste even remotely close to as good as these. I was so excited to star my morning from here we alwayes step by whn coming to S.Island , i recomend deff.-ly!!!

Small place, with small variety of delicious, good quality bagels. Loved their cheddar cheese/jalapeño bagel with egg and cheese. And got rainbow colored bagel with cinnamon/raisin/walnut cream cheese for my daughter and she devoured it. Not the first time here, but it's always a treat

Great authentic handmade bagels. If you want a REAL New York bagel, this is your place.

Bagels By The Bay has outdone the entirety of NY bagels, and dare I say God, with their perfection. These bagels will change your life. I grew up in NY I've had all the bagels. I've since moved out of NY, and for 6 years now I cannot TELL you how often I think of these particular bagels. I've had literal dreams of these bagels. Wake yourself up at 5:00 if you have to. Get there exactly when they open, and experience the joy of a warm Bagel by the Bay. I am currently sitting at my desk, hundreds of miles away, eating a sad grocery store bagel. Please, if you have the opportunity to visit this wonderful place, know that I am shedding a tear of joy on your behalf.