Buttermilk - City of New York

We've ordered all of our children's birthday cakes from Buttermilk, and they have been incredible! The cakes are not only delicious but also beautiful works of art. This year, my newly 5-year-old daughter drew a picture of her ideal cake, and they absolutely nailed it! We can't wait to place our next order. I'm also including some pictures of the other cakes we've received from there!

Buttermilk Bakeshop created the cake for my baby shower, and it truly stole the show at the event. I had a brief email exchange with them regarding my preferences, and I shared the invitation for design inspiration. They crafted a stunning cake that was genuinely a masterpiece. More importantly, it tasted amazing! Everyone remarked on how delicious it was, matching its beautiful appearance. I'm thrilled to have some leftovers in my fridge! I will certainly choose them again for my next cake order!

Love this place and pick up a small selection of baked goods from here about once a week! The chocolate cake in a jar is my absolute favorite. I also love getting the cake of the day slice, the cookies, and the bars. Had the raspberry pop-tart recently (pictured) and it was amazing! Have never had a bad experience in anyway here.

Thank you Buttermilk Bakeshop for the tasty cake and cupcakes. Your team provided great quality items. Review: I chose this bakery because I wanted to purchase from a shop that had a clear and organized website. I was drawn by their variety in birthday cakes. Wow, I never had a dessert before that was just the right amount of sweet. Even the icing wasn’t overpowering in sweetness. If you don’t like dry cake this place is for you, it has a good amount of moisture. If you do decide on this cake and have OCD be mindful the top layer of chocolate is hard so it is noticeable when candles and toppers pierce through, but I didn’t mind. My daughter’s birthday guests all gave compliments to my choice in dessert. Will purchase from them again!

We requested a custom cake for our daughter's first birthday and provided a picture of what we had in mind. They did an incredible job! The cake was a rainbow inside, which was just perfect for our sun-themed celebration.