Paneantico Bakery - City of New York

I absolutely love this bakery! They offer an amazing variety of items—pretty much anything you can think of. From my experience, both breakfast and lunch options are fantastic, and the service is very fast. You HAVE to try the chocolate bagels, whether plain or as a sandwich; they're delicious! Many of my friends also come here for the muffins. The atmosphere is wonderful too!

One of the best bakeries in Brooklyn. Consistently reliable quality. Some of the best cookies and pastries you can get. Rainbow cookies are perfection. Amazing spot for lunch and bricken oven bread sandwiches of any kind.

The traditional cherry pie is absolutely delightful! Please don’t add more sugar, as the current recipe strikes a perfect balance and tastes incredible. It’s refreshing to enjoy the pie without an overpowering sweetness. The ingredients are top-notch and truly deliver a homemade quality. I highly recommend it!

Paneantico, can you please stop selling me stale lemon cookies? I'm not sure what the issue is, but I’d say about 90% of the time I buy them, I get home to find that they're rock hard and crumble apart. The food here is decent, but the prices are on the higher side—$20 or more for just six small pieces of BBQ ribs and $13 for a 4x6 piece of lasagna. I do appreciate the Italian pastries and the traditional holiday items, though. The cashiers seem to change frequently, resulting in inconsistent and sometimes chaotic service. But seriously, please do something about those stale cookies! *sigh*

Panteantico is a bakery and cafe with a wide selection of high-quality breads, cookies, cakes, pies, tarts and other pastries as well as prepared foods, deli meats and espresso drinks. They make great sandwiches. The ambiance is cramped inside with a nice outdoor area. The service is not great, but it does not seem to matter. Ordering from the counter, especially from the espresso bar is inconvenient.