Shy Simon's Pizza - Council

In my opinion, this is the best handmade pizza you can find. Whenever we travel north and pass through Council, we always make a stop at Shy Simon's.

I experienced extremely rude customer service during my visit. My order was completely forgotten and when it finally arrived, it was cold. I will definitely not return or recommend this place to anyone. They've won awards for being the only pizza spot in town, but I'm sure the locals are treated much better elsewhere.

The pizza here is the best I've tasted in the area, and the service is unmatched! The prices are fantastic too!

Shy Simon's pizza was such a delightful surprise of deliciousness.

After a visit to McCall, we were looking for an on-the-way-back-to-Boise pizza place. The usual in Donnelly showed bad recent reviews, so we went out of our way for Shy Simon 's. We were not disappointed! Fresh ingredients, prompt service, and more than enough portions on the pizza. The Pesto was delicious!