Reginelli's Pizzeria - Cozumel

Nothing I ordered was right. Muffalata came as a meatball sandwich, chocolate cake, a cheesecake. Waitress got nothing correct

Service was great and timely for my pickup. When I picked up my pepperoni pizza while still in the box my first impression was this feels light. When I arrived home and opened the box I saw a pepperoni pizza that was light on cheese. Sauce and pepperonis. A bread pizza! My salary was GREAT! I always considered Reginelli’s a quality pie. Not this time.

A while back we ordered 3 pizzas for a around $100- when I tell you they skipped out, they really skipped out. Very very disappointed. I maybe had 2 pepperonis on one slice of my pepperoni pizza. Crust on a normal pizza was so thin it tore through, very little cheese and sauce (if we wanted thin crust we'd order it) And they raised prices! Skimp and keep same prices or actually give us a real pizza. Reginellis was a favorite for years and sadly, we will be looking elsewhere for a new pizza place … – show

Pretty good food for the prices. The first time we went we were blown away at how good it was. Second time we thought it was better than average but not as good as the first time. Good beer deals on weekdays. Friendly staff. We will return.

Waiter took my order and didn't see him till the check was delivered. Foods good. Pricey but good. You can tell the soup and pastas are pre-made and probably frozen/put in the fridge for a period of time. The music was a bit loud imo. Pizzas are delicious though.