Tin Cup Ice Cream Desserts

Great small ice cream place. Portions are good sized and ice cream prices are definitely a good value. The ice cream (sorbet, actually) I had wasn't too sweet and had plenty of fruit bits in it. I'd say it tastes like homemade ice cream as advertised, especially with the lower sweetness. Indoor seating was good, but I have to deduct a star for the frankly dilapidated outdoor seating. The paint is chipped on all of the outdoor furniture, and they don't appear to be tended to for cleanliness.

Really good ice cream, only authentic in Crested Butte so very good! One thing is the service was pretty unorganized and it took about 20 minutes to wait in line. Otherwise really good place.

Just meh, I mean I’ve never met ice cream I haven’t enjoyed though so it’s still good, did have some fun flavors (lemon chèvre goat cheese something) but overall pretty lackluster, not many standard flavors. Their milkshakes might be the way to go, they looked like there were a lot of other options!

I love this Honey Lavender ice cream. Great job to whoever thought about this combination. The honey comb bites in it is just giving nice texture. Amazing!

Honey Lavender ice cream is the best. It looks plain like a regular vanilla ice cream but don’t let the look deceive you. The flavor is the bomb!