Papa John's - Crystal Lake

I recently completed a survey for Papa John's after a frustrating experience where my request was overlooked. I had asked for my pizza to be left uncut because I was concerned about cross-contamination with meat. To my surprise, I received a thoughtful response! A representative from the store reached out to me directly, explaining that they use a separate cutter for vegetarian pizzas, which was very reassuring. They even offered me a promo code for my next order. I truly appreciated how the team went above and beyond to address my concerns and improve my experience. Thank you, Keri!

We ordered two pizzas with two toppings for $5.99 each. Both pizzas—one with peppers and the other with Canadian bacon and pineapple—were fantastic. We'll definitely be back!