Caffe Italia - Deer Park

I have tried gelato all over the world, but this place in NY is my favorite. Other gelato places are subpar, using artificial coloring and flavors. However, Cafe Italia uses natural ingredients. You can easily spot the quality of their gelato by its dull colors and real pieces of flavor. The Hazelnut and Pistachio flavors are exceptional, but everything they offer is delicious. I highly recommend this place, as it is truly top-notch. The cappuccinos and coffees are also amazing. I believe this gelato place surpasses even those in Italy. Don't miss out on trying Cafe Italia – it's a perfect spot for a romantic date.

Every flavor of gelato weve tried is delicious! My husbands favorite is the mint and mine is the Stracciatella. So good! We order from here every now and then as a treat. We tried the mixed berry mascarpone cake once also but unfortunately it wasnt fresh. The berries were mushy and wrinkly on top. Everything else from here has been great!

Oh my goodness! This is now our favorite frozen, heavenly dessert!

The gelato and Belgian waffles at this Long Island restaurant are the best I've ever had. Unfortunately, one of my orders was missing, but other than that, the desserts are a perfect 10/10.

Great Italian desert