Pizzalley's On St. George In St. August

Great pizza spot, a little pricey but you get what you pay for. They had a very unique pizza with chicken pickles and ranch which seemed a bit extreme but ended up being very tasty. The traditional pepperoni pizza also did not disappoint! The sauce was very flavorful and had a very crisp crust. All around very delicious and would eat here again.

Errin?? I belive was the hostess by the Sidecar entrance, she mentioned a special on the italian flagged items at 50% off or $15.00 the plate instead of the full price. We were sold, wenorder the 2 drinks and appetizer (muscles) and rhe pot roast and lasagna.however when we went to pay our bill was the full price. If any one could clarify how is it that this deal works, that would be great.. Other than that... amazing food, great service, fantastic atmosphere. It was was within lunch time.

Zero complaints, best kept secret in St. Augustine. Definitely recommend! Plus they had an epic soundtrack, music was so good.

Great place,Enviorment was awesome great music and nice bartender didn’t take to long good food

As a former restaurateur , I can honestly say we have never had a worse dining experience in recent memory . We were seated, and in the course of the first 10 minutes , several servers walked past us, never acknowledging our presence . We asked for water, menus, and continued to be ignored as though we were invisible . Finally , one server offered an explanation that there was a new waitress, and therefore we most likely were assigned to her. Then , this same server begrudgingly brought over water and menus , and was less than happy having us added to his tables. This same attitude continued throughout our dining time never taking a drink order, walking by and sneering at us if we asked for anything. The table next to us, (that came is at the same time), had finished their meal, had the leftovers bagged to go, before we even had our appetizers. We brought this to the attention of several of the restaurant staff who had walked by during our meal. Eventually, some stepped in, finally apologizing for this waiter’s behavior, stating that he had personal problems . This may be but his lack of regard to paying customers was outrageous . I would not recommend this eatery even tho they reduced our bill. Why pay anything for this horrendous experience .???Do not eat there for just average food. save yourself from this below average dining experience .