Jersey Mike's Subs - East Rutherford

The sub was average, with the main issue being the bread. The quality and quantity of cold cuts provided were not worth the price - there was only about 5oz of meat on the entire sub for $17. The person slicing the meat should try to be more friendly and smile. This experience took place on April 19th, 2023 at 1:30pm.

The food was good, but there is one major reason why I can't give this place a 5-star rating. The person working the register should not be making sandwiches at the same time. Touching cash with gloves on and then using those same gloves to make a sandwich for the next customer is not hygienic. They should be changing gloves to ensure proper food handling practices. Not good.

This location is by far the best jersey Mikes I have ever been to. The reason is Sam! She is incredible! Always welcomes you with a big smile and makes incredible sandwiches. This team is efficient and cares about the quality of the food they prepare. Great job to all. Rob

Would rate 0 stars if I could. Made a $50 order, and informed the person on the phone 3 times that I don’t want any bell peppers on neither of the 2 sandwiches. My sandwiches have more bell peppers than there is meat or bread.

Last night I called last minute and gave these guys the impossible task of making me 20 subs in about 20 minutes. (Last minute food for a hungry HS hockey team! When I got there 20 minutes later they were done, bagged and ready to go! Awesome job!! The boys were very appreciative!