Portside Pizza Tolly Inc. - FAIRPORT

This little place is a total little gem that I would have never known about had it not heard about it from some family. We were going to be out about in Fairport and decided to order dinner for pick up giving us some time to run our errand and get there. We used GrubHub to order and they had a 5 dollar off coupon for your first time order which was nice. We placed the order and within minutes of submitting it we got a phone call from someone at the restaurant informing us that one of the items was sold out for this evening and asked what we wanted to replace it with. We ended up with two chicken parm dinners. We ended up 15 minutes early to our pick up time and they were in the middle of starting our meals so we knew it was being made fresh. The restaurant is small but smelled amazing. When we got home we saw just what our family was talking about the portions are HUGE! But not only is the portion huge but it was backed with great flavor. We got a two huge pieces of garlic bread with actual garlic, not powder. And a good sized side salad, I recommend the greek dressing. The sauce tasted homemade and the chicken was definitely prepped there and the breading was flavorful and the chicken was juicy. We have enough food left over for 2 more meals. We will come back and try some of the other items on the menu that sounded good. Really recommend you check this restaurant out.

Michelle prepares dishes comparable to the food we enjoyed in Italy! So much flavor and attention to just the right spices for every entree! Large portions too! We have ordered many things on the menu and we’ve never been disappointed. Great job on catering also!

Terrible food and service! Worst I’ve eaten in years. Could not get my drink right! I wanted tea they brought coffee!

Michelle really knows how to cook and serve it up right. From huge and I mean huge subs to fabulous Italian to wonderful fish fries. We have enjoyed everything we have tried which includes the chicken and eggplant parm, sausage sub, steak sub, chicken salad wrap and more. Everything is like home made because it is. She cuts the deli meat for each sub. She fills the cannolis only when you order them so they are still crisp. Try it, you will be pleasantly surprised.

We chose La Bella Mangia to cater a family gathering over Columbus Day weekend at Mendon Ponds Park, and we were extremely impressed with the food. The delivery was perfectly timed as well. The chicken French was delightful, and the chicken Parmesan was equally great. We absolutely loved their tomato sauce. The roasted potatoes and vegetables were spot on, and the mac and cheese was a crowd favorite. We’re really happy we ordered from them and will definitely do so again the next time we need to cater for a large group. Thank you so much, Michelle and team!