Gus's New York Pizza - Goodyear

Food was excellent, service exceptional We tried the wings, pizza, baked ziti, Mac and cheese, spaghetti and meatballs and the bread knots. Everything tasted homemade, and not sour-y like other 'italian ' places. The only comment would be that the spaghetti could have been warmer, but since it was for my 5 year old, it was OK. My kids were given dough to play with, they loved that. It is reasonably priced, but is not fast food priced (obviously).. party of 7 payed about $70ish plus tip. The server was more than attentive. Very impressed we will be visiting again soon for sure.

First time at this location and hands-down one of the best spots I’ve been to yet, extremely friendly service phenomenal food and atmosphere will definitely make you want to come back for more.

Excellent pizza, and that's coming from someone who just moved here from New Jersey!!!! If you're looking for a good east coast style pizza, this is the place....

Bad Bad Bad experience. Having a going away party for our neighbor, So every one came over to wish them well. I ordered the 32 pizza from GUS'S to feed 12 people. Picked up the pizza on time and when we started we found the bottom was burnt black. Called the restaurant and was told the manager was in a meeting. Never got a call back. Very embarrassing, people couldn't eat any of it except the few pieces in the middle. TOOK pictures but to little to late.Never again

Today I called in a pizza order while on the road traveling with 6 people in one vehicle for pick up. When I arrived at the restaurant we asked if we could eat in and I would be buying additional items and include tip for the pizza as well as though we were eating in the whole time. The hostess said yes and we took our seats but then came back to tell us the manager said no we can't (no fault of hers she was nice) It was approx 5-530pm on a Monday (not a holiday) so you get the picture... it was not busy. More than half the restaurant was empty in-fact when I entered the front staff wasn't even attending to anyone they were standing at the register waiting to assist customers. It makes zero sense that the restaurant would not want tips for their waitress and more money from us. They weren't packed there was plenty of seating and no wait time. The only thing I can conclude in this scenario is that they have horrible customer service and do not like making money or maybe it was just our money and they were discriminating against our group. Even after explaining to the manager we were traveling and had been in a car for hours he could care less but did oblige by refunding our money and taking the pizzas. At the end of the day all we wanted was a quick pizza and to be on our way to get home. We got that but not at Gus's nor would I ever return to this or any other location based on this treatment. I totally get it if they were busy and there was a wait, but in this scenario there was zero validity to asking us to leave.