Old Chicago Pizza Taproom - Green Bay

We tried to eat here on 2/22/24. Sat ourselves at a high top in the bar area around 1:30pm since there was no hostess. There were approximately 6-8 people eating in the bar area. The bartender/server didn’t acknowledge us for over 10 minutes. She made eye contact with us multiple times but did not even say “I’ll be right with you.” She was mingling with a few people at the bar and made sure to collect her tips from the 2 booths she had served. No drinks, menus, or even hello. We walked out. Worst service (or lack thereof) we’ve had at any place in a very long time. Won’t be back.

Pizza was over cooked. Not enough sauce. It was a Chicago style pan pizza.

We were there (2/17) and our waitress was extremely rude! She was very snarky and when one person wasn’t sure what they wanted she very rudely said “well it sounds like we’re not ready to order so I will come back later” even though she already started taking our order. Needless to say we will not be going back because of her. The food was good but the service was terrible.

Maybe an off night. But service was poor with maybe 16 people in the restaurant and most at one table. Food was missed on the ticket (which they did catch and let us know), all of the calzones ordered at the table were raw and doughy. Pastas were dry (it’s ok to use sauce). The quality has seemed to do a deep dive here. If you want a $27 large Little Caesar’s pizza be my guest, but I doubt I will return.

Not only was I served the wrong food but the service was quite slow for it being dead. My bacon tasted more burnt than “peppered”. The bun was hard and stale. I counted out 14 fries on my side which is crazy. Only reason I’m giving a 2 star is being the pizza was pretty good.