Blue Sheep Bake Shop - Green Brook

That was the most beautiful and tasty wedding cake ever. Put your hands down. My reception was over a week ago and people still talk to me about this cake. It was vanilla cake, butter cream outside and guiana cream inside and it was just incredible, not too sweet or heavy. We can't wait to order our baby shower cake from here. Definitely a customer for life!

Great, fantastic place for custom orders! Very accommodating, pleasant to work. And the quality of work is class A. We found our eternal bakery! Thank you. Karen; the cake was a beautiful, delicious vision!

I picked up a cake for my husband's birthday today. This cake was just one of many ways to go cake. I had no pre-order. Nice and delicious!

Had made a top favor cake for my son's first birthday party. Not only the cake looked fantastic, it tasted just as good! Amazing! The Macaroons are supposed to die. The best place ever!

If I can give 10 STARS I TOTALLY WOULD!!!! Found an image of an amazing cake for my daughter's Sweet 16 and was a little unsure if they would be able to pull it off but wow was I wrong! Taste, texture, and the outside of the cake was SPOT ON!!!! EVERYONE WAS SOOO AMAZED EVEN MY DAUGHTER SHED A TEAR OVER HOW BEAUTIFUL IT WAS. I have been going to Blue Sheep for quite some time now and they never disappoint. A little pricey but you pay for convenience. Communication was also fabulous. They had contacted me over my daughter's vacay just to ensure the cake would be perfect to our liking. They definitely DELIVERED!!!! Thanks again to the baker's at Blue Sheep until next time!!!