Papa Kelsey's Of Hagerman - Beoordelingen

Everything here is fantastic! This is our favorite Papa Kelsey's in Idaho, and I will always recommend it!

As a person with celiac disease, I often struggle to find pizza that won't lead to cross-contamination. However, I can confidently say that the pizza here was f...

They typically serve generous portions of ice cream. We often opt for the single scoop, and it's always very satisfying.

Quick service and friendly staff, even as 7 of us came in a short time before closing!

Really solid pizza. Good timely service. I'd recommend it.

I’ve dined here a few times in the past, and the food was decent. However, I ordered finger steaks that didn't quite resemble the traditional version. They were...

I love papa kelseys roasted underpants! I usually get the roasted ham and cheese or the steak, but this time I decided to sink and truthahn. her pommes/ sauce a...

A pizza for carry ordered after work, and there were added surcharges that should not be there when I came home, I called them back to criticize it without answ...

I wish they had paid a bit more attention to the special requests. Both times I ordered, my sandwich didn’t have any tomatoes on it as requested. The food is ge...

The Italian Combo Sub is just as delicious in Hagerman as it is in Twin Falls. One sub is plenty for two people, but I can easily devour an entire one on my own...

I've dined here a few times in the past, and the food was decent. This time, I ordered finger steaks, which didn't quite resemble what I expected. They came wit...

I absolutely adore the toasted subs at Papa Kelsey's! Typically, I go for the toasted ham and cheese or the steak, but this time I decided on the ham and turkey...

I ordered a pizza for carryout after work, but it had toppings on it that I didn't request. When I got home, I tried calling the restaurant to resolve the issue...

Wish they paid a little closer attention to special requests. Two out of two times sandwich no tomato has ended up with tomatoes... Food is otherwise good and p...