Mchales Catering - Highland Heights

I just had McHale’s at my friends wedding reception. I have food allergies and the staff made sure I was taken care of and well fed. Excellent!

I first knew of McHales years ago when my cousin worked for them and had them do her reception. I've since witnessed them pulling off beautiful celebrations several times after that not once have they left anyone I know disappointed. However, I don't think anything has been equivalent to the challenges faced in pulling off the most important celebration to me yet. My Daughter, Olivia Son-in-Law, Tyler began planning their wedding and reception two years prior to the da

After the nightmare of COVID you made a blessing out of such disaster.

We used McHale's Catering in September and loved the entire experience. Communication was quick and professional, and the food was fantastic. Thanks for everything!

My family, immediate and extended, were at a wedding recently at New Riff, catered by McHale's. The consensus was that the food was terrible. We started with hors d'oeuvres. The mini crab cakes and caprese on French bread were pretty decent. Although, most of the capreses were missing the basil, they still tasted good. The mini egg rolls weren't crispy but, kind of soggy, like they were steamed. Which made them chewy. The flavor wasn't bad but, the inside was more of a paste, than a normal egg roll. Next was the salad. It was a standard house salad. It was honestly the best thing they served, although quite small. Now to the main course. The roast beef was both super salty and very peppery. Plus, it was tough and a bit dry. The tomato and feta stuffed chicken had such a pastey consistency on the inside, that it made it un-enjoyable to swallow. A bit salty too. The country green beans were rubbery. The vegetable medley was supposed to be steamed but, were raw and hard. The mashed potatoes were ok, not bad. The mostacciollis were incredibly bland. (Half the guests, my family, are Italian, so it was disappointing for us. Not to mention EVERYTHING on the buffet was either ice cold or barely luke warm. I'm not sure if this was just a bad night for them but, I couldn't in good conscience recommend them after this experience with their catering. Maybe others will have better luck.