Nino’s Pizza - Hillsdale

The food at this pizzeria is decent, but don't rely on the estimated delivery time. I placed an order around 6pm, and the website estimated delivery between 5:30 and 5:45, which was acceptable. However, the order arrived at 4:20, much earlier than expected, as my guests were not arriving until 6pm.

Do not order delivery from this restaurant. I decided to give them a second chance, but for the second time, they arrived 2 hours late and the staff was rude.

We had not been here for a while, but decided to visit since it is conveniently close. What a disappointment. I ordered an Eggplant Parmigiana Hero. Took my first bite and knew I made a mistake. It was like eating a bread and sauce and cheese sandwich. The sauce tasted like diluted tomato paste, but what was worse was their excuse for the eggplant. It was sliced so thin that you could not taste nor recognize it was eggplant. It was still breaded which added to the bread on bread taste. A total ripoff. We will not be back! By the way, our server whose name I think was Angelina was terrific, pleasant and professional.

I wanted to bring my husband to this restaurant since I have had their pizza before, and it was really good and overall tasty. After my husband and I had the pizza, it did not taste the same as when I had it a year ago, which I was disappointed. The drunk slice was lacking flavor . The grandma slice was really good. The mozzarella sticks were warm, but it wasn't that hot feeling for when you bite into it, the cheese is melting. I was disappointed about this place.

Really amazing food in a pretty unique spot. I really enjoyed the cheese that they had and they plant was fresh has ever.