Fat Olive's Pizza - Hinckley

The crust is just the right thickness, not too thin or thick. The vegetables taste incredibly fresh and the cheese is delicious. The service is great for takeout, perfect for a dinner meal. The prices are very affordable, ranging from $1 to $10 per person. The food, service, and atmosphere all get a perfect 5 rating. I highly recommend trying the Meat Lovers Pizza and the Fat Olives Special Pizza.

I had an incredible experience at this restaurant. Our server, Olivia, was absolutely fantastic. If you are visiting Homer like we were, I highly recommend this place.

I recently returned from Colorado and was craving a delicious pizza with hot giardiniera. To my delight, this restaurant offered both mild and hot options! I couldn't resist trying their Italian beef pizza before indulging in Portillos the next day. Colorado doesn't have the best pizza options, so I couldn't settle for just one. We also ordered plain cheese, veggie, and sausage/pepperoni pizzas, all of which were fantastic. As someone who used to work at Waterman Pizza Villa, I can't wait to visit Fat Olives when I'm back home. This restaurant will now be a must-stop for me. I also want to give a shout out to Chumley's in Shabonna, as they are not competitors but offer great pizza as well. I could eat pizza every day! Let's make Route 30 a pizza destination! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

First time customer. I ordered the Oliver. Taste's GREAT! Service: Take out Meal type: Dinner

Ordered for the first time yesterday. Great flavor and plenty of toppings. Next time will ask for extra sauce though... just reheated leftovers in the air fryer and the crust crisped up nice!