Andrea's Dining Room - Long Valley

There’s a sign on the door that reads "Closed for the Winter," even though OpenTable allowed me to make a reservation. We enjoyed our last visit, and I hope they will reopen soon. However, they need to update OpenTable to let people know they’re currently closed to avoid any further inconvenience.

The staff is friendly, the service is excellent, and the food is fantastic. This place is definitely a must-try!

The service at this restaurant leaves much to be desired, as the only staff member I consistently saw was the waterboy. It seemed that the management may not provide adequate training for their waitstaff; I had to wait 15 minutes for a drink refill while my server chatted with the manager. The food was decent, but nothing to get excited about. The most frustrating aspect of the evening was that all the outdoor doors were locked, with only one back door open. This raises concerns about potential fire code violations at this establishment.

Food and service were absolutely amazing! Have only been there twice now but it's been fantastic both times! Must haves are the limoncello calamari and the pumpkin cheesecake!

Was looking forward to trying Andreas for my wife's milestone birthday. Had a reservation and arrived on time. Were told there would be a wait of at least 20 minutes. Not a good start. Restaurant has very little space to wait didn't offer a place at the bar (it was crowded. We were seated in approx 20 22 min and it went down hill from there. Our server came over took our order for drinks two martinis and a bottle of Pellegrino. 20 minutes later our drinks still had not arrived, we had to flag our server down to ask for menus inquire about our drinks. She apologized about the menus, the drinks took 10 more minutes. Our meals were very tasty, prepared as per menu but our spirits were definitely diminished by the apparent careless attitudes of the staff. Coffee tasted like diner coffee, not equal to the restaurant's food and if there were any specials that evening we have no idea, as they weren't offered and by the time we ordered our food we were too hungry to remember to ask.