Mario's Pizza - Lynchburg

My wife and I wanted some pizza after a long day at work (8pm on a Tuesday). Our normal choices were closed. So we decided to stop by Mario's for the first time. I got their stuffed pizza which was amazing. My wife is a spaghetti expert and she was impressed with their spaghetti and meatballs. The employees were very nice and had a real family feel. We will absolutely be back.

If you can handle a place that is a little on the dark side, this is a must. Four stars only because they could spend a little more time cleaning the dining area. That aside, some of the best new York style pizza around. Everything is made from scratch and the flavors are amazing. Stop by have a beer or some wine, order a pizza or calzone, you won't be disappointed.

I've been coming here since 2005. I love this place. The food is always on point and the staff is always great.

Authentic New York Style Pizza! In town visiting Liberty University and wanted something different than the usual pizza chains we have back home in Ohio. Everyone was very nice to us. Although we did hear two employees have an argument in the kitchen. It wasnt loud or a big scene or anything. But I felt bad for the lady that brought us our drinks so I gave a big tip. The man in the kitchen was very mean to her. Hope they worked it out! The food is delicious!

We order here four times a month and tip $10. Every time we order the same thing it keeps getting higher. The works on a cheese steak went from $13-$14-$16 FOR THE SAME EXACT ORDER! LOYAL CUSTOMER HERE WILL NEVER COME BACK. Y'ALL NEED TO TREAT LOYAL CUSTOMERS BETTER AND STOP BEING GREEDY