Gotham Bagels - Madison

I went to buy Bagels today not to realize that they only had an online order system. My order quickly placed in about 2 minutes. Less than 2 minutes later I got a text saying that order was ready. Bagels and cream cheese are definitely amazing.

Bagels are chewing and delicious. Cream cheese flavor selection is full of savory choices. Order the app to compensate for waiting time. The banana bread was really dry. The part was huge, but it was tasteless, dense and drrrrry. Hold on to the bagels.

I love her Bialys and her bagels. The taste of the bagels calls memories of the NYC Bagels...but he does not import the water. And I LOVE they're delivering. They are my goal for family meetings, and especially Sunday brunch. Whitefish salad, Lax, Black and White cookies... and even Dr. Brown Sodas. Makes an East Coaster, transplanted to Wisconsin, a little less homesick

The Bagels themselves are still good enough for the Middle West, but the New York Service-Schtick runs thin when your food is not available until an hour after the promise

Sandwiches are always great but since the pandemic and closing of the main dining room, other service has suffered. I've always loved their Cream of Wild Mushroom soup and occasionally the Chicken Tortilla (warning spicy and it builds). With the current online ordering...soup is all you get. Pre-pandemic you'd get a nice handful of bagel chips but since the pandemic, nothing. No crackers, no bagel chips, just soup for $6/bowl. Do the left over bagel chips really cost that much extra that they have to be ordered ala carte? Today I added the black and white cookie and am very disappointed. It's the size and quality I'd expect to get on an airline. That's a normal soup spoon and normal sized hand in the photo. Each cookie is $1.