That Pizza Place - Madison

We stopped here to get some food on our way back home from a family reunion and boy was it worth it! The food made here tastes absolutely delicious! I worked at a pizza place before and i do not eat pizzas often because of it, but i would totally go back here again and again from how great it tasted! That marinara sauce was made with passion!!! The only crime I can think of is that I dont live close enough to get food often from here, but other than that; this will be a go to stop when going on roadtrips now We we're also told by one of the lady's who worked there that the store would be combining with the seafood restaurant next door to it due to lack of business starting next week.

I usually LOVE everything about ordering from here. Today was 100% different. I ordered early online. Pizza was 15 minutes late for pick up when I ordered 2 hours earlier than pick up. My husband was told that “they forgot about it.” We ordered a large pepperoni and lemon pepper boneless wings. What are normally amazing wings were cold, frozen in the middle, seemingly store bought junk. My $20 large pepperoni pizza wouldn’t pass for a medium at a chain store and was 50% puffy crust and 50% overcooked/burnt cheese and pepperoni. This was by far the most disappointed I have been in a long time.

Small and cozy. Best pizza in Madison. Service was very good. Greek salad was delicious and the pizza was perfect. No soggy crust here, unlike their neighbor's pizza. Only place we go for pizza. No beer served there, though and no carry in. Still, 5 stars.

Really good food, and excellent customer service. My family went here on a roadtrip, and we were very happy with our experience. Their attention to detail was impeccable.

Do not ask for Delivery. Called the store and ordered food at 6:50pm. Was told by the woman who took my order that it would be 30 min. No big deal. Called the store back at 8:10pm to get an idea of what they were doing. I specifically told the same lady that I could eat from other places if they couldn't deliver. And that I didn't want cold pizza. They arrived at 8:26pm. Pizza was cold. Sub was soggy like it had been soaked with water. Called the store back after paying and asked what happened and explained that this was exactly what I was trying to avoid. The woman who claimed she was the manager, but also refused to give me her name said she didn't see what the problem was and that she would fuss at the Delivery guy. Let me stress 100 that this was not the Delivery guys fault. This was caused by not telling me they were 1.5 hrs out on Delivery. If you've been to the restaurant and received good food and Service , great! However Delivery for this place was not worth the wait. And I even gave her the opportunity to just let me know they couldn't get me food. She lied. She made excuses. She blamed the driver. Then she became disrespectful. Do not order Delivery from this place. I'm literally 1.4 miles from them. No excuse validates telling me 30 minutes. Had she told me the wait was 1.5 hrs I would have declined and eaten elsewhere. Again , this is not the Delivery persons fault.