8 Fifty Wood Fired Pizza - Middlebury

My bride to be and I have lived in Middlebury for a couple of years. We absolutely love the menu, the owners and the staff. It's rare to find an establishment that is able to maintain a steady workforce and quality of service.. Says a lot about ownership. If something is not right, tell them and they will make it right. Don't leave mad, not say anything, and then go home and write a bad review. I assure you, they will make it right.

This was by far my favorite pizza place when it opened, I had never had anything so good (pre covid). Unfortunately, all of the recipes and ingredients seem to have changed and it just doesn't hit the same note it used to. I can only hope the new owners can go back to doing things the way it used to be. It was truly one of a kind previously. Whats worse, is that my original review raving about this place is posted on their website, and after three trys under new ownership that review is no longer relevant.

Went before for the shrimp Mozambique and I asked the owner if the sauce has any alcohol and he said absolutely not. Came back last weekend and I asked the chef again and he said yes it does contain wine . I was so very upset as I don’t consume alcohol in my food. That was not an honest thing from the owner. Not so very cool and will never come back again

I live in Middlebury and this is the first time I went to this restaurant. Generally, it was very good. Apparently they have expanded the space in recent times and have installed a very large bar with high tops. I had the Jagger pizza with vodka sauce, cherry tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella. It was really quite delicious and I believe it was made in the Napoletano style. Very thin crust, slightly burnt edges, and a little chewy as it should be. The waiter was very friendly and helpful, albeit a little inexperienced. I will definitely come back and try other menu items.

Never ordered here before, I was passing through Middlebury and I googled pizza in Middlebury and just called to order a 12 inch pizza, with meatballs on half and caramelized onions on the whole thing.They asked me Red? I said yes.When I was told $22.38, I nearly said forget it. But, thought Well, this must be real good and decided to go for it.In my world, pizza comes with cheese,Unless you specify no cheese.I was very disappointed to pay $22 for some dough and a few toppings.Maybe that 's just the going rate in Middlebury?To be fair, the sauce and meatballs were good, if not plentiful.No thanks on this place!