Star Island Yacht Club - MONTAUK

Like many years, we dropped off 5lbs of fluke/seabass fillets for the takeout “you hook’em we cook’em” deal..they did a fantastic job (Blackened, General Tao’s and Tempura), delicious and doesn’t come any fresher then that!! Staff were very accommodating, food trays were well presented..added rice and we had more than enough for our group of 5 with leftovers..hence why we keep going back to them!! Food: 5

Excellent food and drinks while watching the sunset, clam chowder and tuna sandwich were very good Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Recommended dishes: Baked Stuffed Clams

Very nice place and dog friendly. The gift store/fishing store is cool too. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

I absolutely loved my experience here! It was my first visit, and everything was fantastic.

It's interesting to see such differing opinions in the reviews! Personally, I found it to be a mix of good and not-so-good without leaning too far in either direction. Overall, the appetizers were decent, though nothing extraordinary. I opted for the blackened fish on a Caesar salad for my main course, which turned out to be a safe choice that I was quite pleased with. One of the highlights of dining here was the ability to accommodate a large group without the need for a reservation. This is definitely a strong point, as the meal was solidly average. Additionally, the restaurant is a stop on one of the booze cruises available for booking in Montauk, so that can help you gauge what to expect in terms of dining experience.