Siena's Pizza - Monticello

I have dined at all the restaurants in Monticello, and without a doubt, Siena stands out as the best. It’s a family-owned establishment, and they prepare all their meals from scratch on-site. The pizzas are the finest in the area, boasting a perfect crust, sauce, and toppings every time. The Italian dishes are reminiscent of something made in the Old Country by a loving grandmother! They also offer American cuisine, including burgers and similar dishes, which are equally fantastic and generously portioned. You won’t find any skimping here! The staff is very friendly and attentive, striking the perfect balance of being helpful without being intrusive. The dining room is comfortable, featuring both booths and tables, including a large table in the center for bigger parties.

Delicious food and friendly service! We loved the chicken roll and were really impressed by the beautiful presentation of the Mozzarella Caprese appetizer we also enjoyed.

I used to really love this place, but I had some issues with the management and their lack of business acumen. They now have a policy that limits you to 10 minutes for a $10 lunch deal, which was frustrating for me. However, I noticed that the woman who seemed to be causing problems has improved, and the pizza is now really delicious. Because of this positive change, I’m increasing my rating to 4 stars.

Sienna's Italian grocery store is a fantastic place! The service is excellent, and the staff is incredibly welcoming. The food is always delivered hot and fresh, and if there’s ever an issue, they resolve it immediately. I’ve never had a problem! If I ever needed to change an order, they handle it without any hassle. I highly recommend Sienna for delicious Italian dishes like pizza and eggplant Parmesan. It's a wonderful place for families!